ChatGPT (We need to talk)
Created on:2023-04-17 16:00

Since its launch in late 2022, ChatGPT, the artificial intelligence chatbot developed by OpenAI, has experienced rapid growth and widespread adoption. However, its role in education remains a highly debated topic. Some see it as a tool that enhances learning and reduces teachers' workloads, while others regard it as a threat to integrity, opening the door to cheating and plagiarism.
Dr Vaughan Connolly (VC) is a teacher and researcher whose research interests are the role of technology in education and teacher workload. Dr Steve Watson (SW) is a co-convenor of the Faculty's Knowledge, Power and Politics research cluster, and uses social systems theory to explore the meaning and spread of ChatGPT.
VC: ChatGPT represents a turning point in the development of AI, and we teachers cannot afford to ignore it. For educators, it will be as transformative as Google was in 1998, and it requires a serious conversation about the benefits, challenges and impacts it brings to schools and learners. It will profoundly change the future. Educators must begin to engage with it in a meaningful way.
SW: I think ChatGPT is a very powerful assistive technology. It is transformative for generating text and coming up with ideas. Historically, most communications innovations have sought to improve semantic communication in order to avoid misunderstanding. In many respects, education is also concerned with this. I would urge educators to start from this perspective and think about what ChatGPT can and cannot do.
VC: With its rapid development, especially the iteration from version 3 to version 4, the discussion about banning it has become irrelevant. As these systems train themselves, the transformation will accelerate, and all of this is genuinely already happening.
The question is not whether ChatGPT can be used in schools, but how to use it safely, effectively and appropriately. Schools need to tackle this proactively, or they risk putting themselves and their students at a disadvantage. I do think this issue is very urgent for the education sector. I worry that our response falls short of the urgency of the moment.
SW: We must step outside thinking purely in terms of dystopianism or boosterism; ChatGPT brings new opportunities and complexities. So far, it has mainly been described as a content-creation tool. In fact, generating content may be its most basic function.
Where it excels is in manipulating structure and form. Everyone seems to be worried that ChatGPT can write an essay or coursework that passes an exam, but this means educators need to adapt and say, "All right, what can we do with it?"
VC: I use ChatGPT in my GCSE computer science lessons to prompt students to verify viewpoints, seek more detail and question information. These conversations have been truly illuminating. I have also tested it as a homework and revision tool from the perspective of students in different subjects and at different stages.
For example, I pretended to be a Key Stage 4 history student and had a rich conversation about nineteenth-century cholera. We can imagine situations in which it might genuinely help students revise, check homework or edit essays. It has also helped postgraduate students with English as a second language clarify what they mean in their writing. They can give it a passage and ask it to rewrite it in an academic style. The results were impressive; it reduced these students' translation burden and allowed them to focus more on the content.
SW: When I was at school, my problem was that I had a head full of ideas I wanted to express, but sometimes did not know how to express them in the right way. This technology can help students express ideas in a clear, well-organised way and in the right form, so that teachers need only focus on the ideas themselves.
In the process, it can shift the focus of education towards critical thinking and big questions. Because it can also summarise an argument, knowledge and concepts, it genuinely has the potential to support formative assessment, especially when teachers' time is limited.
VC: My greatest concern is that we cannot ignore it. It is already widely used, and copying it costs far less than inventing it. Some negative consequences have already emerged – for example, the recent problem of the Snapchat-based chatbot My AI directing users towards harmful behaviour. The ubiquity of this technology means educators need to understand how to use it, the associated dangers, and how to encourage safe use.
SW: Innovations like this are always a double-edged sword: we cannot simply see them as heralding the arrival of a new utopia.
In many ways, it recalls the "Deep Thought" supercomputer in Douglas Adams's novels: we are strongly attracted by the prospect of something as a highly intelligent and knowledgeable source of information, but it is not a trustworthy, independent source of information. We cannot remove the human operation from ChatGPT.
The challenge for educators is to explore its capabilities and limitations and to put them to use.
VC: The first thing I observe is that the same problem affects many digital resources, such as Wikipedia and Google search. The creators of this technology need to ensure that it is trained on diverse datasets from different countries and different languages. If I worked at a large educational institution, I would pressure the developers to do this.
At the same time, teachers have a responsibility to train students to use the technology correctly. For example, I often explain to students that a Google search on a particular topic may carry inherent biases in terms of gender, culture and race. For any good educational programme that teaches people to use technology wisely, these considerations are indispensable.
SW: This brings us back to the possibility that people may mistakenly use ChatGPT as a source of content and knowledge. We have already seen cases of people criticising it for this, for example posting on Twitter that they asked it for a list of 10 famous philosophers and it gave them a list of 10 white men.
It is important to stress that this is an assistive tool: its main value lies in its ability to change the structure and form of text while preserving meaning. Educators should be aware of this and emphasise its limitations as a source of knowledge.
VC: Rather than restricting the use of ChatGPT in education, institutions such as the Department for Education should hold those who provide these services accountable, thereby minimising the possibility of harmful use. This could potentially be achieved through legislation such as the Online Safety Bill.
Digital skills are already part of the curriculum, so the government should consider how to ensure that schools teach students to use this technology safely and effectively – just as they are already supported to use the internet safely. I would like to see this important training become part of not only PSHE and computer science but also other curriculum areas, ideally led by experts with a deep understanding of such technologies.
SW: Regulation is indeed an issue, and we must respect the need of universities and schools to protect academic and educational integrity. That is why some universities consider students' use of ChatGPT to generate content to be misconduct.
The problem is that, in our efforts to maintain integrity, we may respond slowly to these inevitable changes as the technology is adopted at scale. If we over-regulate ChatGPT, this gap will widen, and institutional positions will become untenable.
VC: Just as when the iPhone appeared, institutions should bring together staff from different departments, including academic and non-academic staff, to explore ChatGPT and move forward step by step. It is our responsibility to ask: "What is this, and how do we use it?" If you teach maths, can it help with revision? If you are a computer science teacher, how can it help students learn to program? From a workload perspective, can it speed up your lesson preparation? We need to address this from the ground up.
SW: Bear in mind that we cannot simply introduce this technology and expect it to work. We need an iterative process of design, development and field research. There will be many people – especially students – who are far ahead in this area. If we can harness this energy by getting a group of people to collaborate and test, then we can develop guidelines and structures around the technology. Education research centres such as our own Faculty have enormous scope for collaboration with other schools in this regard.
VC: I do not think schools can afford to wait for the government to tell them how to respond. Distributed leadership models are necessary, bringing staff together to discuss the use of ChatGPT. School leaders need to create time and space for discussion. It is equally important to recognise that students' appreciation of technology is more nuanced than we sometimes give them credit for. The people I have spoken to are concerned about avoiding ChatGPT becoming a shortcut in education, so that it does not affect their learning. It is also very important to involve students in the conversation.
SW: In this situation, the traditional approach of regulating potential threats to the way educational organisations operate will not work. That is why we need to see collaboration between executives and practitioners to determine how it should be used. ChatGPT shows us that we cannot always control, predict and calculate our response to educational risks from the top down.
Conventional decision-making hierarchies need to delegate authority so that different parts of the education system can test and improve it – while maintaining continuous dialogue with leaders and executives.

